logoalt Hacker News

Copilot edited an ad into my PR

1433 pointsby pavo-etctoday at 4:04 AM600 commentsview on HN

Comments

hexasquidtoday at 5:25 AM

I'm so tired of what initially looks like a perfect normal communication between two people, only to find that some third party has inserted itself like a parasite to exploit and extract human attention. That's why I use our sponsor, nord vpn ...

croestoday at 8:45 AM

Sent-from-my-iPhone 2.0

6510today at 8:41 AM

I don't see an ad, I see a warning. I like it.

upmostlytoday at 6:50 AM

Isn't this the same as

"Sent from my iPhone"?

shevy-javatoday at 7:52 AM

I have a somewhat similar problem with github issue templates. They automatically stuff I don't care about or would propose and structure things in ways I don't like. Granted, I can edited this away, but it requires extra time and makes filing issues more work than before. Biggest case in point is the "I will adhere to the Code of Conduct". In general I do not care about CoCs and it is fascinating how CoCs leak into everywhere for some so-called "open source" projects. They don't seem to understand the issue when the licence does not require a CoC; even then the issue is not about the CoC in and by itself (though I also find them pointless), but that extra content is automatically added to issue templates in general, CoCs just being one of many spam-options. And I also recall some donation-ads that are automatically added too - I have no problem when projects request financial support, but if I file an issue then the issue is about the content of the issue, not about anything else.

anshumankmrtoday at 5:34 AM

One more step closer to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAM1rSObk4c

vcryantoday at 6:04 AM

I'm not a fan of LLM's injecting themselves into PR/commit content. If you use multiple models, basically whichever one is operating git gets all the credit. But, even if you wrote all the code yourself, and just submitted the PR with Claude Code (or whatever) it would attempt to take credit for the changes.

I currently have rules in all of my skill files forbidding models from advertising themselves or taking credit.

show 1 reply
j45today at 3:58 PM

It's the hotmail signature all over again?

withtoday at 5:29 AM

Everyone is doing this now. Granted, on Codex / Claude Code, you can disable it, it’s not the default to have it disabled. For some reason on Cursor, they keep shoving the “Made with Cursor” into my PR description despite me disabling attribution, which looks really stupid on a work PR.

I’m so tired of all this BS. Why did this become normal? and how do we not read this as cheap advertising?

show 1 reply
daemintoday at 5:25 AM

Using a LLM to fix a spelling mistake is retardedly lazy.

Presumably they used a free version of the LLM, therefore it is completely understandable that it inserted a snippet of text advertising its use into the output. I mean using a free email provider also adds a line of text to the end of every email advertising the service by default - "Sent from iPhone" etc.

show 3 replies
GN0515today at 5:31 AM

But... why?

show 1 reply
charcircuittoday at 5:56 AM

This looks like an ad for only Raycast which does not appear to be affiliated with Microsoft or GitHub at all so blaming Copilot or GitHub here is not justified.

Edit: The link in the promotion goes to https://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/use-copilot-agent...

Which does show that this is affiliated with GitHub unlike what I thought. There are no mentions of this string in a code repository on GitHub (including the Raycast copilot extention).

MattGaisertoday at 5:54 AM

Post the trajectory if this is real.

show 1 reply
hsbauauvhabzbtoday at 5:48 AM

It was only a matter of time.

Sent by my iPhone using tapatalk

lpcvoidtoday at 3:57 PM

Once again, Microslop doing Microslop things

show 1 reply
zippolyontoday at 8:29 PM

[dead]

techpulselabtoday at 4:07 PM

[dead]

weiyong1024today at 4:06 PM

[flagged]

imta71770today at 3:54 PM

[flagged]

bustahtoday at 12:47 PM

[dead]

devnotes77today at 2:05 PM

[dead]

mergeshieldtoday at 4:22 PM

[flagged]

panavinsinghtoday at 4:10 PM

[flagged]

ryguztoday at 3:43 PM

[dead]

wendy7756today at 4:14 PM

[dead]

martmulxtoday at 11:07 AM

[dead]

winnatoday at 6:04 AM

[dead]

wazionappstoday at 3:14 PM

[dead]

allssutoday at 3:17 PM

[dead]

minsung0830today at 6:39 AM

[flagged]

claytoniatoday at 6:02 AM

[dead]

treysutoday at 6:30 AM

[dead]

sta1ntoday at 4:02 PM

[dead]

aplomb1026today at 5:31 PM

[dead]

lancetheaitoday at 2:59 PM

[dead]

tourist2dtoday at 10:15 AM

[dead]

ookblahtoday at 6:03 AM

maybe every PR should be run through 2 other llms so they just remove the ads of competitors (or i guess you'll end up with all 3) /s

10keanetoday at 5:42 AM

[dead]

riverforesttoday at 2:44 PM

[flagged]

i18nagentaitoday at 7:03 PM

[flagged]