logoalt Hacker News

aucisson_masquetoday at 9:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

Immigrating to the usa is not a right. It is granted.

I don't see the problem, and I'm not even American or Trump supporter. It just makes sense.


Replies

pixel_poppingtoday at 12:52 PM

That's what I just commented as well, I'm not from the US but that seems so obvious, in which country it's a "right" of some sort? It should definitely be hard, maybe even very hard to emigrate there, to show strong commitment and intent and most especially you should have something special to bring to the table knowing you didn't abed by the same rules growing-up (not the same level of education necessarily and so-on) which is a bit unfair for local citizens.

I don't really understand the position of many comments which seems to be somehow "We should be welcoming the world" but like why? Why wouldn't you prioritize your citizens first especially seeing the job loss lately?

show 1 reply
callmealtoday at 2:13 PM

>Immigrating to the usa is not a right. It is granted.

It's not about rights, it's about keeping your promises.

"Join the army and get a green card" -- oops did we say that?

But then we have only been fair weather friends (see how we treated pretty much any one who put their lives on the line) so I'm not very surprised at what's happening.

show 1 reply