logoalt Hacker News

Oracle bans AI-generated code from OpenJDK

430 pointsby delducayesterday at 5:36 PM291 commentsview on HN

Comments

herodoturtleyesterday at 5:57 PM

[dead]

Ozzie-Dtoday at 1:33 AM

[flagged]

throwaway613746yesterday at 6:38 PM

[dead]

rootnod3yesterday at 5:55 PM

[flagged]

show 1 reply
dist-epochyesterday at 6:06 PM

Oracle is not a software company, but a litigation company. It will be hard to sue people because LLMs generated code similar to some code copyrighted by Oracle if they themselves use LLMs internally to generate code.

CamperBob2yesterday at 6:32 PM

Hilarious thing is, if I want a JDK, I'll ask Fable to write one, get Sol to review it and write tests for it, and it will be working by Monday morning. No need to get permission or anything else from Oracle. Building a complex product from many smaller, individually-testable components is exactly what LLMs are good at, and a Java SDK certainly qualifies.

And if I run out of tokens, well, that's OK too. K3 running on my own box will finish the job. I'll just have to wait another week, that's all.

show 2 replies
andrepdyesterday at 8:05 PM

Never get high on your own supply, says the dope peddler.

27183yesterday at 5:58 PM

What happens to OpenJDK when Oracle dies? That's looking increasingly likely on a 3-5yr horizon.

show 5 replies
mbrumlowyesterday at 6:06 PM

Policies like this will result in the death of the branded software.

As we move forward it will be easier than ever to just maintain and keep your fork of software with the changes you want or need. No more approval, bureaucracy, or arguing. Just tell the AI agent want you want changed and you have it.

This will be used for huge things too. Like maybe you want a specific fork of Java that only supports for each iterators, goodby linters, hello compile time error.

show 13 replies