logoalt Hacker News

Growing proof that autonomous cars save lives

354 pointsby bookofjoeyesterday at 5:14 PM619 commentsview on HN

Comments

foxtrot8672today at 1:18 AM

obviously true, and it has a lot of other benefits, such as being able to take a nap while driving.

BoingBoomTschakyesterday at 6:13 PM

The article sensibly asks if the (intentionally or not) cherry-picked stats about automated driving (fair weather only, limited to specific areas that aren't especially difficult) is valid then cites a study that really massages those stats in a dubious way (e.g. only counts as a crash if the airbag triggered, no mention of weather). Hmmm...

Another thing I'd really like to know: let's suppose that these are indeed safer than the average driver. Is it also the case for the median driver?

BatchJobtoday at 1:23 AM

The lack of transparency and misinformation coming from the industry players and the NHTSA cast serious doubts on any "science" around autonomous car safety being possible.

If it was really known the full extent of the cover up it would probably be termed a conspiracy between the autonomous car companies, the state DMVs and the federal authorities.

It will take many years and many more unnecessary deaths before we know the truth. THEN give me science based on real and complete data.

show 1 reply
superkuhtoday at 6:28 AM

Growing proof that autonomous cars save lives in cherry picked temperate and clear environments that don't get things like snow. The article mentions this point and acknowledges it is a serious problem and then just leaves it at that as if it doesn't completely demolish the entire argument they're making. They don't try to refute it or anything.

>How Does Limited Fair-Weather Data Compare to Traditional Crash Statistics?

>A key question is whether Waymo’s robotaxis, currently limited to fair-weather operation in a handful of cities in the U.S., are directly comparable to humans driving a wider variety of roads in much more variable conditions.

That's literally all they say about the subject before moving on to talking about incomplete sampling of true crash rates.

SoftTalkeryesterday at 8:21 PM

Growing proof that driving attentively, sober, not playing with your phone, and not speeding saves lives. Actually, we've known that for a long time.

kevin_thibedeauyesterday at 8:33 PM

Didn't save Elaine Herzberg.

Lammytoday at 12:58 AM

The System loves leaning on the Cult of Safety to justify taking away people's autonomy and freedom of movement

goda90yesterday at 9:39 PM

A vision of a possible future where capitalism might go with the rise of self-driving cars: https://youtu.be/040ejWnFkj0

Rover222today at 3:31 AM

This is real and good news. Autonomous driving systems have gotten very good and safe (well, Waymo and Tesla FSD).

Taking vehicle out of the hands of humans WILL save hundreds of thousands of lives around the world.

Yet most comments here want to complain that we should be building public transit instead. Glass is always half full on this topic for some reason.

wolfcolatoday at 2:46 AM

what about when an autonomous car kills someone, and the car company remotely deletes important onboard logs to avoid culpability?

show 1 reply
jeffbeetoday at 1:31 AM

I love this conversation as the death spasm of driver culture. On the one hand, a lot of hard data. On the other hand, myths.

usernametaken29today at 1:14 AM

Honestly, mount a front and back dash camera, and allow people to submit tickets for speeding and tailgating themselves.

I’m not kidding excessive speed and not keeping a safe distance equates for some 50% of all deadly traffic incidents. It’s because a small and vocal minority drives like absolute fucking assholes and they will rally lawmakers not to introduce speed limits and to loosen grip on enforcement. The ADAC (German motor association) is a perfect example. When they announced after decades that they support a 130km max speed limit members jumped by the doves.

The only vastly meaningful improvement I can see in FSD is faster reaction times when it comes to assholes. Coincidentally those are the people who insist on driving petrol and will never upgrade to FSD because they like to drive like assholes.

IMHO it’s time for strict enforcement. Let’s ban them from the road finally. Set fines in percent from income. Allow self reporting via dash cams. Add stricter penalties for recurring offences, if you’re caught speeding 5 times in 2 days your licence is suspended.

That’ll have a much bigger impact than FSD. Maybe we can rally our representatives making them all giddy with all the extra cash they can earn from these offenders?

show 1 reply
Vaslotoday at 1:10 AM

I feel like we never get real data on autonomous cars as we never do with data centers. It’s hard to tell if bad stories are anecdotal or rooted in truth. I hear the vast majority of accidents would be things that no human could avoid either - but then I’d also be anecdotal.

hereme888yesterday at 10:28 PM

Tesla has tons of data to the same. Elon ftw.

ErroneousBoshyesterday at 11:59 PM

You have to remember that this is data from the US, where the road death rate is just about level with Somalia, something like 30% of road deaths involve drunk drivers, and something like 50% of fatalities overall are because the casualty wasn't wearing a seatbelt.

Driver training is non-existent, vehicle safety inspections are frankly comical.

I have been driven in a car by an American colleague, supposedly trained to a high standard (former public safety) and frankly I think you could train a pigeon to peck buttons to control the car better.

JoeAltmaieryesterday at 8:49 PM

We'll have arrived at the automated transit network when they stop putting up road signs. The cars know where they are, and how to get there. Signs are for fallible ignorant humans.

show 2 replies
watwutyesterday at 5:41 PM

I was reading about autonomous cars being better then people 6 years ago ... along with cries about the cars are treated unfairly.

dweinustoday at 12:55 AM

Cool, now show the public transit safety numbers.

krautburglartoday at 5:03 AM

Epstein class pays a "journalist" to lie, so that one day, you will have no choice but to purchase their drivable iphones.

lucapratatoday at 9:12 AM

[flagged]

alescalaiostoday at 10:00 AM

[flagged]

dontsubmityesterday at 7:21 PM

[dead]

rotringlvrtoday at 1:39 AM

[dead]

black_13today at 12:10 AM

[dead]

josefritzishereyesterday at 5:21 PM

[flagged]

show 1 reply
nxmsmomtoday at 1:28 AM

[flagged]

DNSDNSDNSyesterday at 9:41 PM

[dead]