logoalt Hacker News

Many of Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday “deals” offered no savings

807 points • by DeepLogin • yesterday at 1:39 PM • 489 comments • view on HN

Comments

subhro • yesterday at 3:15 PM

Lots of people here are saying they can find independent shops with lower pricing. That is true, lots of times, however what makes Amazon come ahead is shipping and 5% cashback with Amazon credit card.

It sucks. :(

ncruces • yesterday at 2:27 PM

Not bad: 2 in 3 are actual discounts, 90% don't leave you worse off.

➕ show 2 replies
lavendermon • yesterday at 7:59 PM

My wife and I only keep Prime because A) she's still addicted to 2 day shipping, B) I can still find promo deals to make Prime free or very cheap. This is our compromise because cycling through signup accounts for Prime promo deals makes returns and finding past orders a bit more of a hassle. I just don't feel Prime is worth anything close to the full price they charge, that line was crossed about 5 to 7 years ago.

Whether or not a slashed price is actually a lower price has been debated for a long time, I don't find this "research" groundbreaking though it does help confirm some hunches.

I did find it fascinating that this news site hyperlinked itself within the first sentence of its own article.

jghn • yesterday at 8:28 PM

There's a resort I like to go to. Every year they have a Black Friday sale. Also, every year, like clockwork, they raise their rates in early November, and then the Black Friday sale just brings things back to the previous price. Go figure.

bix6 • yesterday at 2:27 PM

Amazon is such a scam. They mark things up and then immediately mark it down so they can show you “10% discount”. Can we get some freaking consumer protection laws my god why is this so contentious.

➕ show 3 replies
dofm • yesterday at 3:48 PM

Yes, pretty normal for the prices in the UK to go up 28 days before Black Friday so they can come back down in time for Black Friday to stay within the law. I saw precisely no unusual deals on anything I have been tracking the price on.

(I did find my regular pair of shoes in one of the Prime Deal Days; I basically always buy a pair at that time of year to get new treads for winter, and then wear them flat throughout the year)

WaitWaitWha • yesterday at 4:30 PM

Is it still "Amazon", or just an eBay with built-in logistics?

As in, the prices for Amazon products, the article makes sense, but what percentage of the stuff on it is still Amazon? I assume (and, i do not know) that Amazon has some influence on the pricing, but not full control.

sillypuddy • yesterday at 5:28 PM

Shocking! We should come up with a phrase to warn people about businesses. Like 'let the buyer beware', but make it sound more historic.

xunil2ycom • yesterday at 8:37 PM

Yeah. This has been done by retailers forever.

➕ show 1 reply
yellow_postit • yesterday at 2:28 PM

Every year there are articles about retailers raising prices ahead of the holidays to then claim a discount.

If you need it, and can afford to own it, buy it.

If you can’t, don’t let a supposed deal entice your purchase.

DudeOpotomus • yesterday at 5:06 PM

The rug shop downtown has been going out of business for 10 years. They have $10,000 rugs marked down to $5000.

anjel • yesterday at 3:04 PM

Shopping on Amazon means cutting through so many dark patterns at Amazon these days, the overarching message being, pure contempt for its customers.

➕ show 1 reply
nazgulsenpai • yesterday at 3:23 PM

You aught to see Temu. I often laugh at how everything on there, even when it's more expensive than other retailers, is 90% off!

gavin_gee • yesterday at 5:24 PM

the good news you can see the fake pricing on the amazon website by just looking at pricing history - they literally put the button at the top. Every sale is a scam.

its just the new version of see price in cart

frabia • yesterday at 2:37 PM

Quick tip: install a browser extension like Keepa to see price trends of Amazon products and spot the fake sales.

➕ show 1 reply
Grombobulous • yesterday at 3:18 PM

Which actually means 66% of deals do offer savings.

I’m not even sure I would single out Amazon for this practice. Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time. Just look at what happened when JCPenney tried to eliminate sales in favor of straightforward pricing. Customers hated it because they felt like they weren’t getting a deal, they weren’t getting rewarded for scouting out a “find.”

➕ show 1 reply
balls187 • yesterday at 5:23 PM

Minor credit--they do show you price history up to a year back.

Havoc • yesterday at 2:38 PM

Just check price history?

These days I’m buying a lot of tech off eBay and aliexpress anyway. Pricing tends to be better

lordleft • yesterday at 4:08 PM

I really feel like this counts as deceptive advertising and should be illegal.

PaulKeeble • yesterday at 4:00 PM

camelcamelcamel and Keepa are essential tools for dealing with Amazon, a lot of companies doing dynamic pricing and dodgy sales tactics on it. Amazon is a very poorly regulated seller generally these days.

biker142541 • yesterday at 4:07 PM

Cool to see some numbers behind what we all know already.

mithr • yesterday at 6:06 PM

I mostly keep a wishlist of things I want but don't really need, that I'd get at a deep enough discount. Then during events like BF/CM, I can take a look at the list and see if anything's at a good enough price (it rarely is).

I also find it counterintuitively helpful that so many of Amazon's deals are obviously not actually deals, and that so many of their products are so obviously knockoffs, because when I do find myself scrolling through a "Kitchen sale!" list in the app, it only takes a minute for me to realize this is useless and close the app in disgust.

mring33621 • yesterday at 5:41 PM

Pretty sure everyone already knew this.

wolfi1 • yesterday at 5:10 PM

I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked

croisillon • yesterday at 2:56 PM

suprised_pikachu.jpg

kittikitti • yesterday at 9:17 PM

Big Tech is filled with bots and scammers. The problem is that people don't listen and blindly follow whatever comes out. This isn't news to me, but I don't take everything Big Tech says at face value.

mannyv • yesterday at 7:48 PM

camelcamelcamel

aframemodular • yesterday at 2:59 PM

Honestly I am surprised then that more than 2/3 of "deals" are actually deals. If you do your research on what you want to get ahead of time and what it should cost, shouldn't this still be a great day for online shopping?

morelandjs • yesterday at 2:49 PM

Amazon exposes price history for products. You can see how much something cost under a deal compared to earlier in the year.

andy_b_84 • yesterday at 3:01 PM

They're still bad at hiding their Ministry of Truth activities, such a shame.

mech998877 • yesterday at 2:37 PM

This is not a surprise.

jjyycc • yesterday at 4:28 PM

That's sad!

timnetworks • yesterday at 2:32 PM

The new game is marking things as one-day delivery and then taking the customers money and then not delivering on this promise.

Fuck amazon for doing that. Fuck amazon in general.

Also fuck uber for charing 'waiting fees' for the shitty taxi service, I'm not jumping into a moving car you soul sucking vampires, it needs to be stopped. Fuck uber in general tbh.

➕ show 1 reply
mike_bob • yesterday at 5:41 PM

I got a good idea, let's build something to disrupt Amazon! Remember disruption? Where'd that go? Oh right... it was a grift all along making everything worse and more expensive.

inshard • yesterday at 6:06 PM

The Amazon price history tool now GA on the mobile app is pretty useful. It goes back a couple of years. Heartbreaking to view for SSD and RAM-linked products. But replaced camelcamelcamel.com for me

reactordev • yesterday at 6:45 PM

Amazon is a cancer on the Internet.

If you sell through them, you are not allowed to list your products cheaper than they do otherwise they delist you.

beloch • yesterday at 8:24 PM

Amazon was already far up the enshittification curve back in early 2025 when Bezos started openly palling around with the Trump administration. That's when this particular Canadian started their boycott, and I have to thank Amazon for making that decision easy to stick to.

For those who wish to get off of Amazon, all it takes is a little planning or the willingness to go shopping in a physical store. It's no bed of roses for physical stores these days, but the reports of their demise have been greatly exaggerated. Malls are still alive and well in Canada. For things you need to order, don't expect overnight shipping. Plan a little further ahead.

For those who have decided to stick with Amazon a little longer... Do pay attention to the holiday price shenanigans that are about to take place. It's not just in your head when a book you swear you saw last week at $15 is now "on sale" at $40. Christmas is when Amazon becomes truly rapacious.

lowbloodsugar • yesterday at 5:36 PM

Welcome to America! Decades ago, when I was new to US, I found a 50% of deal at Macy's for a $100 item. Noticed the price tag was on top of another, so I peeled it off, and the original one underneath said $50.

This isn't illegal. Every company does it. If you want to stop it, change the law. Most passive voters on earth.

j45 • yesterday at 5:23 PM

The real black friday/cyber monday seems to happen in January/February.

Online retailers are about optimizing their profits at all times and cases, not what customers want.

People can simply not spend and it will get their attention.

Some years, theres no deals.

Inflation is providing enough boosts in profit that they might not care to give out sales to make revenue.

Retail is about creating profit, not the product.

clint • yesterday at 5:19 PM

Hasn't Wirecutter literally been reporting this for the best part of a decade now? Here's an article from over 5 years ago: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/why-most-deals-arent...

unsharted • yesterday at 3:33 PM

I've made a hard rule to check keepa before Amazon purchases and its probably saved me thousands of dollars over the past couple years. Their practices are absolutely scummy

thraway3837 • yesterday at 3:12 PM

It’s not just Amazon. It’s every retailer. This is because of timing: US holiday season/Black Friday was historically the best time to buy stuff because of deals. So people expect spectacular deals during these sales events.

However, deals now run throughout the year and prices are usually better on random days so it pays to hunt the deal sites or social media. Physical stores also have better deals and are the only authorized dealer for a lot of brands. Big hardware stores also have 2 hour or same day delivery which is amazing. And you’re guaranteed to not get fakes.

ex1fm3ta • yesterday at 2:43 PM

In eelctronics, the items in sale tend to be different from the ones on regular prices. I saw this with powerbank, chargers, usb-c cables ... Visually it`s the same product but specification wise most of the times is quite different.

teeray • yesterday at 3:38 PM

Once again, regulation. Perhaps something like “Discount percentages must be calculated from the 52-week median price of the item.”

alienbaby • yesterday at 4:34 PM

its kinda one of the oldest tricks in the book. I thought there was legislation to prevent it in bricks and mortar stores, at least here in the UK. I guess it doesnt apply to Amazon huh?

prpl • yesterday at 3:39 PM

now do grocery stores

jmspamerton • yesterday at 8:28 PM

[dead]

zquzra • yesterday at 7:33 PM

[dead]

loki004 • yesterday at 7:40 PM

[flagged]

fdefilippo • yesterday at 4:29 PM

[flagged]

🔗 View 1 more comment