logoalt Hacker News

We don't need more apps. We need better open source

309 points • by pandemicsoul • today at 2:45 PM • 200 comments • view on HN

Comments

junixx • today at 3:57 PM

Do one thing and do it well.

- Old proverb

komali2 • today at 3:30 PM

So far, many FOSS projects seem to be taking a hardline no-LLM policy, since they seem to have determined LLM tooling to be a net negative for their projects. I wonder if that's because of their nature as very large projects, or very public projects.

gsoff • today at 4:32 PM

for now it’s hard to make money from a new open source project. people need money, so they can’t work on open source for free. many open source projects that make money today are older projects with an existing community.

mithril_ • today at 3:18 PM

Without open source your average AI probably couldn't even write "hello world". We're going to get slop after slop if developer don't write good open source code anymore.

qwoprunner • today at 5:59 PM

The lack of much-improved open source tools is one of the more baffling things for me when it comes to AI. Especially after Sol 6.1 / Opus 5.5 released, you can whip up a fairly solid application in several days. But... where are they?

OSS devs were sinking a mountain of time into relatively unpaid work, doing unglamorous work. Some of it is in backend systems and console utilities that few people will ever appreciate, but a lot of effort went into user-facing things. And yet, so far I found just one program that replaced one of my mainstays - I went with AI-coded SquirrelDisk to replace FileLight. Everything else is the same, and I just don't understand that. Surely not EVERYBODY rolls their own? Surely some OSS people did embrace AI rather than quitting in disgust?

A small example: tagging music files on Linux is horrible. Kid3 is.. it works, but the UX is almost like a parody. Mp3tag runs on windows and it has a macos version and it's a vast improvement. You can run it through bottles but I refuse to believe everybody does that. Surely people that use Linux listen to music, which leads itself to occasionally needing to tag or rename your audio in batches.

I had some spare time so I rolled my own mp3tag clone that would work on Linux, MacOS and Winblows. I added audio playback to it because opening in external program annoyed me. Then I added some functionality for podcasts to it: being able to search for subtitles, playback speed and such. Then I added the ability to convert between formats, using ffmpeg. Then I added a way to measure loudness, some ReplayGain functionality and the like. Then a way to find duplicates, for making sure those random files you have on that old external HDD can be deleted safely, and a way to search through what you have on all disks, even if they're disconnected, so you don't buy some album you already own like a dumbass.

It took me about three weekends of tinkering with it until it was good enough to switch to it. I keep running into small issues but by and large it's been fairly reliable. It's fairly complex, with a lot of buttons in the view, but given that the 'competition' is mp3tag (which is okay but also ugly) or kid3 (which is both ugly and almost unusable) it's just flat out superior, unless you're happy with mp3tag and don't want all the extra complexity. I don't want to offer unpaid tech support to people on GitHub but I'm considering releasing it and just leaving it there with no further communication and maybe somebody will pick it up. If not, it's still better than alternatives even if there are undoubtedly many, many bugs and the codebase is undoubtedly a tangled mess.

Aside from the ugliness of having almost all functionality without any sub-menus that would give Apple designers heart attacks and perhaps more complexity than it should have (I personalized it for what I wanted, after all), it's genuinely a decent application. It's written in c++, a language I never used. It's fairly performant on my ~15k audio files library. Changing it is as simple as pointing a modern LLM at it and asking in english for some changes. It took me approximately 20 hours to make and the cost was about $10 in subsidized tokens from Claude.

If I, a random guy who doesn't even know c++, can write a usable program in three weekends, then where is all the new vibecoded software? There are so many tools that technically work but the user experience is straight up awful, usually on linux side, or flat out holes that aren't filled, usually on mac side. As best I can tell, very little is being developed. People who have no idea about coding are recompiling console games on pc, in admittedly dubious quality, but people that dedicated years of their lives to OSS... don't?

➕ show 1 reply
lifeisstillgood • today at 3:26 PM

So there is a XKCD cartoon that basically says “14 different standards - let’s build one to fix it all … now you have 15 different standards”

Open Source did an end run round that problem by producing

- better quality code, faster, and replacing the arguments over standards with a level playing field marketplace

As we are learning software has eaten everything but everything has not become software literate - there are hospital MRI machines that are only certified for windows XP. Our supermarket fridges think they are cheap IOT devices for teenagers bedrooms.

It’s going to take a decade or more for society to work its way through replacing all its devices (sewages plants are devices too) wit what is a software literate approach - secure, PKI, monitored updated and … open

No fucker will trust a fridge running a blob of binary - a complete SBOM and a repeatable build will be table stakes

And while we could wait for standards what is most likely to happen is each industry wakes up and starts to say “we want a beyond zero based approach, PKI setup this way, the builds are published and run here and publish the firmware”

Walmart might be thinking about this now - but open source will if we are senile be the backbone

And it will finally be funded as the answer is for industry players to fund the fridge-python api project, mostly by hiring the devs. Or the devs go full pococo and get sponsored

dankobgd • today at 4:12 PM

best i can do is more slop on top of old slop

rvz • today at 3:06 PM

...and who is going to be motivated to maintain all of those open source apps? You cannot fund all of them, and open source has an unsustainable funding problem.

Even worse, most of open source is now majority slop and it is highly likely that they will be abandoned.

drltaidev • today at 5:52 PM

[dead]

NiceWayToDoIT • today at 4:07 PM

[dead]

philipwhiuk • today at 6:37 PM

[dead]

ReDress • today at 4:48 PM

[dead]

ovnz • today at 3:16 PM

I vibereported a few bugs recently. It's satisfying enough to spend 15 minutes on, and easy enough as AI is good at collecting all the details and proofs for you. Also, there's no feeling that you re-used someone else's code through an LLM.

➕ show 2 replies
ex1fm3ta • today at 3:02 PM

Most of those apps are nice wrappers of open source projects. We need better licensing to prevent those vultures from stealing community works.

➕ show 1 reply
dario_amodei • today at 3:57 PM

no