logoalt Hacker News

I'll never buy Framework hardware again

731 points • by unchar1 • today at 4:06 PM • 496 comments • view on HN

Comments

dhuadaar • today at 6:03 PM

I don't understand why people feel offended if this article is written by hand / claude / gpt / someone with IELTS 8 band.

He had an experience he shared. You can consider it and be cautious your purchase or risk and enjoy the support shenanigans.

He paid for a laptop. He can write his support ticket with claude. It's none of the concern for anyone. But framework is contractually bound to fix hardware. ( And ethically too else why even sell stuff in the name of repairable when you yourself can't handle repair )

Hardware faults are out of framework's control. I would assume they get insurance, warranties and also bake in some markup to serve support and replacement.

Poor customer support is a choice they consciously make.

➕ show 1 reply
YuechenLi • today at 5:13 PM

The thing with Framework's setup is that they are really in the exact situation where build quality would suffer the most: Unlike large companies, they don't have the product volume nor the capital for fully automated manufacturing + rigorous inspection/audit, and their hardware are way too custom so they can't use a lot of well tested off-the-shelf parts with the quality assurance amortized like a lot of white box manufacturers.

Big component manufacturers usually tend to not to want to work with somebody like Framework because it's a lot of work for relatively little profit because the lack of volume, which is why the vendor they work with tend to be smaller, cheaper suppliers with weaker engineering/quality assurance.

Framework are fun personal laptops to play around with, but for enterprise, it's probably better to stick with the large manufacturers, as bad as HP/Dell/Lenovo may be sometimes.

InsideOutSanta • today at 4:54 PM

Framework's hardware is great, I love my Framework 13 Pro. But I've never heard a single good thing about their support. Every single story I ever heard was about endless cycles, asking for pointless photographs, and failing to fix the issue.

If anything ever breaks, I'll just pay for the replacement part and fix it myself. Which is probably what they want.

➕ show 1 reply
monomania • today at 5:13 PM

I've bought a few Framework 13's and a F13P. I generally like them, they're expensive, but are very reparable. F13P is a big step up from the original F13.

They're a good value proposition if you think you'll ever damage your laptop enough to warrant a replacement. I was moving boxes once and dropped in on my F13, destroying the display and the lid. I spent maybe $250 and about and hour or two of time, and it was just like new.

I haven't had any of the QC issues people have been talking about.

One big draw for me I haven't seen on other laptops is the 3:2 display ratio.

One thing I wish they'd change is the keyboard. With such easily replaceable hardware, I should be able to get different styles of keycaps and switches.

Another thing is battery life. The F13P is much better than the 13, but it's still not great. Not sure if it's a firmware issue, a battery issue, or both.

hecturchi • today at 7:01 PM

I have a maxxed Framework 13 and the thing just reboots randomly sometimes. I have tried everything but if course I cannot try a different OS and wait for the event to happen as supports wants me to.

This is in addition to a month-long saga of lagging graphics because of kernel issues that was eventually fixed.

The battery lasts 2 hours.

Anyways, learnt my lesson.

ChaseRensberger • today at 4:56 PM

yea, this and a lot of the comments here are obviously bad. I just got my Framework 13 Pro last week and love it but QA, customer support, and the ability to upgrade over time are all obviously big selling points for the company. I hope they improve though, I haven't had this much fun with a computer in a long time.

nebben64 • today at 4:59 PM

I got the original F 13 ... great for learning, experimenting, fixing (and more learning by doing so). But not really a "build once and forget about it" type laptop. Customizations can some time and if you just want it because it's "open" but you're not tech savvy, you're screwed.

355E3B • today at 5:21 PM

To offer an alternative perspective to the large amounts of criticism here. I have been enjoying my Framework Pro immensely. Granted I was laser targeted as a Linux user who had a Macbook Pro because of the build quality/battery.

Hearing some of these stories has made me a bit scared if I ever have to deal with Framework support. I understand they are a much different company than Dell or Apple, so they face different constraints, but I'd hate for them to disappear because too many people are burned or are afraid of being burned by them.

It really seems like they're dedicated to learning from feedback, so I really hope their support team can improve their process and break through their reputation.

prophesi • today at 4:57 PM

You're either a small, lean company with a small and undertrained support team (The Framework community forum is the best way to find actual support). Or a large, bureaucratic nightmare hoping to send you away before you ever talk to a human.

The Apple stores break this mold, though you have to find and drive to one. And I had an M2 Macbook that needed repairs twice in a row for the same issue. Thankfully the first repair was just barely still under AppleCare, while the the second was covered by work. Because I'd otherwise be fuming for how expensive the repairs were, and that they didn't fix the original issue. No longer using that machine, but I wouldn't be surprised if it'd have broken a third time by now lol.

➕ show 1 reply
Brass • today at 4:30 PM

Wow.

Stinks because I need to replace an aging MacBook and was leaning Framework.

Is Omarchy on a MacBook the way to go for mobile Linux these days or?

➕ show 14 replies
rajeshvar • today at 6:35 PM

I purchased a Framework 13 DIY edition in Oct 2024, my machine would not boot. While this behavior is not acceptable on a freshly shipped product, Framework support was helpful in debugging and I was able to return it back by Nov 2024. The return process was easy.

I then waited a bit longer for the AI 300 to ship and purchased that in April 2025. This machine has been my Linux server where I run my docker containers and claude sessions [I use it more like a server type machine], and my photo library and occasionally use it like a laptop. I'm happy with the keyboard (not such much the trackpad). My daily laptop is a macbook m3 pro.

The initial Fedora 43 experience was a bit rough, but for the last 6 months or so, the framework 13 has been a really good workhorse machine running Fedora 44. I'm considering upgrading my disk to 1T (512G installed currently) and possibly swap to a framework 13 pro after a few months.

There are some risks to new vendor but the alternative is that big tech companies will force you and nudge you down a path where your choices are limited over time. Framework is a welcome alternative, and if you have extra $$, it is good for enthusiasts to vote and encourage competition in the marketplace. While the Macbook M3 is close to a perfect machine, every software release being shipping by Apple causes more deep integration with the rest of the ecosystem forcing you to keep all things Apple and this is not good for the consumer in the long term.

Also, with volume, if you are a school or a software company - Framework gives you some benefits on maintenance, moving memory/disk from one system to another, if one mainboard fails, you can replace it. Framework puts in a lot of effort into upgradeability [eg: from 13 -> 13 pro], I'm not sure how much of that is worth the effort - as I'm guessing as a vendor, you will make some design tradeoff choices on backward compatibility vs being the best of breed for the future. In some of these cases, facilitating a marketplace, where folks can trade in seems more appropriate. Testing the different combinations of choices I'm thinking is also a nightmare - as certain combinations may not work well, making customers unhappy, dealing with returns and aggravation with debugging seems like a problem that framework should not be solving.

I also really enjoy the youtube videos that Framework produces -- really educative, talking about design tradeoffs and discussing competitor products as well. I'll really hoping for Framework to be successful as a company.

drnick1 • today at 4:59 PM

What is so great about Framework anyway? These days Linux runs out-of-the-box on just about any business laptop. AI can quickly verify compatibility or even write/patch whatever doesn't work.

zebark • today at 8:26 PM

I gotta go to the mat for framework here because I have been a long time user and I've had plenty of issues with the hardware and will still support them till the day I die.

I bought a framework back in 2021 and I've had plenty of issues with it over the years. I've also had plenty of issues with literally every other piece of technology I own over the same period of time. And I have been able to repair precisely zero other pieces of hardware save for my desktop pc.

When I first bought the framework the hinges sucked- They sent me new hinges and I replaced them and now they suck slightly less. I broke my bezel, I bought a new bezel. I thought the battery sucked and it did with the first Intel main board but after upgrading to an AMD board and after several iterations on the firmware, it now has doubled its on time while still being at 80% of its original capacity five years later. I got the cooler master case for the Intel board and yeah it didn't fit! Did I throw it in the trash and vowed and never support New Hardware ever again? No, I got a nail file pegs and I spent an hour sanding down the pegs and used a little elbow grease. Did it fit perfectly? No. Should it have been fixed originally? Probably. Do I now have a fully functional mini PC that I still get to use every day? Yes!

The first generation charger is dumb and constantly wants to connect and disconnect. The trackpad had to be replaced and my bottom cover is breaking. Plenty of issues and none of that is surprising given that the company is literally only five years old.

Even after all of the upgrades and maintenance, I'm still operating the most customized personal laptop I've ever owned. The most trustworthy laptop I've ever owned- I feel genuinely confident that if something goes wrong I can fix it. And even with all of the purchases I had to make to continue to keep it up to date. I've still spent less than what I would if I had to replace literally one Apple computer, and now I have a perfectly modern laptop as well as a perfectly functional mini PC.

No company's perfect, no device is perfect. Sometimes framework has fucked up my email replies other times they've gone way out of their way to accommodate my needs and have been exceptionally patient with me. Everybody's human and polemics like "I'm never going to buy X again" are inherently click baitey. The original blog is actually not even posted anymore probably because framework reached out and tried to make things right.

abc42 • today at 6:18 PM

Just get Lenovos people. Solid quality. T, X or P series and if you're installing Linux on it, make sure you get something that was released at least a year ago.

Sure, it's made in China, but seems like there are worse places on this planet.

csnover • today at 5:29 PM

And here I thought that this was going to be about how, after almost three years, the Framework 16 still has severe firmware bugs that cause the CPU to be stuck at 550MHz[0], it doesn’t work with various USB devices[1], the audio expansion card is broken[2], and USB-PD is broken[3]. And then every new firmware update seems to come with some regression[4][5]. And the community submits patches and they are just ignored[6]. I don’t get it.

[0] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[1] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[2] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[3] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[4] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[5] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/SoftwareFirmwareIssueTr...

[6] https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/EmbeddedController/pull...

tptacek • today at 4:51 PM

I'm just struck by the idea of ordering a new laptop, finding a hardware fault in it, and then arranging to have them ship a part. Is this a weird Framework thing? Return the laptop!

Framework appears to have a 30 day return policy. What's the logic in trying to salvage a bad laptop?

facorreia • today at 6:42 PM

> The laptop arrives early August. Q assembles it

That’s the first problem. Who thinks that assembling a laptop that was just bought is reasonable?

> powers it on and is greeted by a “missing input module” screen

That’s an immediate return, not a series of support emails. Doesn’t Framework have a no questions asked return policy?

The entire chain of interactions is justification for a chargeback.

Trannosaur • today at 6:21 PM

It's funny because having owned a few annoyingly defective laptops from multiple brands, this is how I expect support to go with anyone but Apple, but actually, I would've expected better support from Framework too.

NordSteve • today at 6:44 PM

Having gotten caught in similar loops in the past, I have a simple rule for new hardware.

If it doesn't work well enough to keep on the first day, it gets returned.

alsetmusic • today at 6:20 PM

> At this point, Q is no longer a developer but has become a profesionnal photographer.

Wow. That’s a great line.

I was a fan of Framework, even as an Apple Guy. I always enjoyed seeing news about them. This is disappointing.

dnautics • today at 7:05 PM

I wonder if Framework should just not offer tech support. You either RMA it or repair it ypurself

radku • today at 5:14 PM

FWIW I've used Framework 13 multiple generations and cannot be more happy. It delivers on the modular promise.

On one occasion I had to contact support, they were very helpful and I don't mind doing a bit of diagnostic myself. Hopefully this is a one off.

susanthenerd • today at 5:34 PM

I'm feeling the same about them. I like their mission and I want the mission to succeed, but damn the company is scummy.

So long story short: I got my framework 13 (12th gen) back in August 2022, in Austria. For those who didn't experience that intel generation, a very common bug is the 400mhz locking even when cpu is cold. In 2024 I had them replace the motherboard due to the bug. Than in 2025 it returned. Since I bought the laptop in austria I was entitled to a repair (austrian warranty law guarantees 2 years again after any replacement/repair). They refused and I had to threaten them with filling a notice at the consumer protection agency for them to react after a lot of time. They shipped me a new amd motherboard, and that functioned for about 2 months before it shorted I believe. After that I had to again spend about a month and a half with support until I forced them to return my money.

I also have a post on reddit about it with more details: https://www.reddit.com/r/framework/comments/1rx76l6/psa_for_...

reshux • today at 4:39 PM

I got a Framework 13 in 2021. I was so excited to use it. I had to repair it multiple times, first when it was 2 years old, second time when it was 4 years old. I know the point of having a Framework is repairability and upgrades, but I never had to repair a laptop before, especially during the first 5 years.

I first had to use it as a professional dev device in late 2025, before that it was just a light personal laptop for me. It suuuuucked as a dev device for me. I got a Macbook Pro again.

Their customer support experience is slow and really infuriating, even for design faults they admitted and for things they offer free replacements.

evadne • today at 7:55 PM

The article body has disappeared

pzautke • today at 8:03 PM

As a long-time ThinkPad user, the Framework 13 Pro is the best laptop for Linux you can buy (well, pre-order) today. It's the first laptop I've owned where using Linux isn't attached to any form of trade-off vs. Windows.

Every machine in the ThinkPad lineup is somehow compromised: good screen but terrible battery life, good battery life but terrible screen, decent trackpad but feels kind of "meh" in Linux, etc. etc.

t1234s • today at 6:58 PM

I like the idea of framework but low volume products give you low volume problems.

regnull • today at 5:10 PM

I'm confused. If it was broken out of the box, why not just return it?

t-vi • today at 5:03 PM

I would probably buy a Framework again for being able to replace parts, but my experience with the support has been meh as well.

I had a known-broken[1] keyboard (Del Key on the Framework 13" AMD, from Batch 3, October 2023) and contacted support with it.

Apparently their support had some e-mail viewer breaking on ">" (dropping everything after, which is terrible when quoting with text mode E-Mail). That drove me crazy because they kept asking for the same thing over and over again. I reported it on the forum[2] but did not receive any response.

When I finally figured out their email bug, they asked me to switch OS and record the keyboard not working on video. I ended up buying the replacement keyboard because that seemed better for my sanity.

I did replace the CPU fan as well, and it worked well, even a bit smoother than with ThinkPads. I also replaced memory. I like their documentation for stuff like this.

Recently, the camera has become unreliable, quite likely the routing of wires through the hinge breaks the cables after I opened and closed the laptop a few times.

I still mostly like the hardware and the philosophy.

1. https://community.frame.work/t/solved-broken-delete-key-like... 2. https://community.frame.work/t/support-e-mail/75541

numlock86 • today at 7:04 PM

I never got the appeal of these in the first place. Sure, replacing/reusing parts is a nice idea. But it's essentially nullified by their weird pricing. Ecological? Sure. Economical? Absolutely not. Everyone that owns a Framework that I know turns out to be a massive LLM fanboy, and honestly I think without that (biased) marketing no one would really give a damn about them. Other than on YouTube all I hear is bad things about them, e.g. getting bricked by _recommended_ BIOS updates and other weird hardware quirks.

hoppp • today at 6:32 PM

If you want a good alternative to framework check out Tuxedo

Very high quality and extremely good support!

tomaytotomato • today at 5:13 PM

If the author of this post is here,

Please, I will buy it off you, I am desperate for a Linux machine that is cool :)

I used to run Thinkwares but I want something a bit more stylish

opengrass • today at 6:28 PM

$3000. Congrats on falling for memes while Thinkpad and rMBP parts are plentiful.

edumucelli • today at 5:29 PM

I was thinking about buying one as my next to replace Dells that have been super reliable for years now ... let me keep my Dells.

reedum • today at 4:57 PM

I have a 13 laptop that is now 16 months old and has had multiple issues with the display. I am on my third screen with the exact same problem as the first 2, a line that runs from the top to the bottom right where the hinge is poorly attached and rubbing on the display. I sent pictures, I sent videos, I talked to different bots that were all too stupid to understand. Like this guy, the 1st time I dealt with support they claimed it was OS related; because my drivers were out of date... That is odd when the line is present at all times when the screen has power applied. I sent them videos of this, narrated them and put subtitles on it. After 21 emails, they sent me the first replacement screen. The 2nd time, it took 27 emails. The third time, after just 4 emails, I said fuck it and decided to run it as a desktop now. Their mediocre hardware just isn't good enough to have to deal with their shitty support.

tebruno99 • today at 5:35 PM

yep, same problems with Framework myself. Got the 11g had issues never resolved after dozens of photos and back and forth. Replaced for the 12g, had to wait years for security updates, for the battery to actually be supported, never got the announced Thunderbolt compatibility.

Framework sells "fixable" but abandoned junk.

kaboom3 • today at 5:13 PM

The reality is that it is far easier to purchase a used dell latitude or Lenovo Thinkpad off of ebay or craigslist and just update the memory or storage. I recommend integrated intel or AMD graphics though.

trentor • today at 4:35 PM

Same. Horrible experience all over.

➕ show 1 reply
bejd • today at 5:22 PM

I received a Framework Laptop 13 Pro last week. DIY edition, but it was more simple to put together than a desktop PC. On realising a corner of the trackpad haptics weren't working, I contacted support. I'd already performed some basic troubleshooting which they didn't ask me to repeat, and after a couple of rounds of sending some photos (including, like in the article, the packaging box) and videos, they think it's a hardware fault and have escalated the ticket for a replacement input cover.

Until now, each response took a day or less, and felt efficient without any repetition. The latest response does have that worrying boilerplate that they're "currently experiencing a high volume..." so I'm hoping it doesn't all go downhill now.

All in all, the fault was disappointing but these things happen. The rest of the machine is wonderful and, coming from a MacBook Pro, I'm very happy. This may change if I have to wait weeks for another dodgy trackpad though!

eikenberry • today at 7:49 PM

So who sells a well-made, reliable and repairable laptop that runs Linux well? Seems like every single one has major issues in some area and there are no good options. /sigh

gedy • today at 4:49 PM

YMMV but son's Framework 13 AMD has been great with daily use for 2+ years, very solid. I plan/ned to buy one before RAM prices killed my enthusiasm for any computer purchases...

maelito • today at 5:36 PM

Got my framework 13 for a year or more, very happy.

numpad0 • today at 6:22 PM

Sounds like a typical tolerance stackup and/or frame rigidity issue expected of a low volume && modular product. When you're not Lenovo and you're not shipping 1m unit/year, nor you're Sony with decades of miniaturizing things too much, nor were you Apple with obsessive pursuit of frame rigidity and Foxconn as a partner-in-crime, but you did have bunch of modules that easily come out and go in... you get combinations of parts that passes unit tests but fail integration "tests".

darksim905 • today at 5:06 PM

not to be a jerk to the person who posted and I get it, people expect things to work out of the box, warranty support, etc. but after all the frustration with the first keyboard, why didn't they just order a replacement? Isn't that... like, the whole point?

0xdeafbeef • today at 5:18 PM

Same story with the software part. Good thing it's OSS. Bad that nobody cares to even reply to PRs.

My FW16 sometimes doesn't charge with chargers <100W. Spent, I guess, half a year lazily hunting it down. Found the issue: it was missing cleanup. Stage 4 disabled charging, stage 15 or something very late failed and forgot to turn charging back on.

Sent a PR, posted on the FW forum. No answer after 20 days. I've fixed it for myself, but what the hell.

https://github.com/FrameworkComputer/EmbeddedController/pull...

catapart • today at 4:52 PM

I love what Framework claims to be and have always held them as one of the companies I will check out when it's time for a hardware refresh for myself, but after reading this they are 100% out of the question for me.

If there's one thing in the world I will not tolerate any more than I am literally required to, it's this absolutely intolerable type of "support" that has become the norm in this country. This whole read reminds me of trying to get help with cars, phones, digital services, apartment rental - basically any place where I have ever called in to, they all act the same. No continuity of service between agents, no actual interest in "solving the problem", a complete and utter subservience to their "script" or their ways of "trying to help" (which is a set of processes or utilities that are targeted at the 90%, not the people who have actual issues).

For anything that I have any control over purchasing, I will not subject myself to that kind of customer service. It makes my blood boil talking to these people and hearing them just repeat the same bullshit over and over without ever actually engaging with what I'm saying, or recognizing that what they are suggesting couldn't possibly help me, with an indifference (or worse, arrogance) for my situation.

If this is the type of support that Framework provides, I hope they fail. I hope every person there gets dragged down by the company's dumb-as-fuck focus on the product and not the relationship. It's always gotta be both and these libertarian-lite MBAs have to learn that one way or another.

FrameworkFred • today at 6:05 PM

This is disappointing.

I have a framework 13 amd and I adore it. Bad support can ruin anything though and it will absolutely break my heart if/when I experience that.

I do hope they figure out how to improve their support experience, because I'll definitely research it before I make another major purchase from them. And I really want them to be where I buy all my laptops from in the future. It's soo good.

dmitrygr • today at 7:19 PM

So what you will, but a MacBook would have simply been replaced in the Apple store the same day.

vvpan • today at 4:40 PM

It is hard to be a small manufacturer, especially with the lofty goals of Framework, let's keep that in mind before throwing too much dirt.

➕ show 1 reply

🔗 View 29 more comments