logoalt Hacker News

aunty_helen04/26/20254 repliesview on HN

Australia is an island and islands are weird places compared to continental countries. Border security is ridiculously overkill and there’s a mentality that you can just keep x out permanently.

The first time you go from a country like this to the mainlands it seems weird they don’t check for things like having an apple in your bag when crossing borders.


Replies

jey04/26/2025

I’m pretty sure you are supposed to declare agricultural products at customs. Sure, if the apples are cooked into a pie that’s probably fine but I believe most countries don’t let people bring in fresh fruit because of the possibility that some pest (insect, fungus) could be hitching a ride on it.

show 1 reply
trollied04/26/2025

England/Wales/Scotland form an island. None of that is true.

show 3 replies
nandomrumber04/26/2025

If there's one thing Australian's all agree it, it's that carrying fruit across certain state boarders is generally a bad idea.

rootsudo04/26/2025

Nah, there are many island nations in the world, especially in oceania. Only NZ and AU are particularly overkill and security for x and y.

Case in point, I go to Indonesia and Philippines - I buy produce in either country to bring to the other country, full declare it, show it - no one cares. Several kilograms as in 10kg+.

Meanwhile, airplane gives passangers apples on flights to New Zealand (or was it AU?) and they all get fined $1000 upon entry if they kept it.

Now why do I bring produce from an country to another? Cost and availability. A green pepper costs $4-6+ in Philippines. It's less than 30 cents in Indonesia.

So, to reiterate no - it's clearly Aussie/NZ overkill.