logoalt Hacker News

Thorrezyesterday at 11:03 AM2 repliesview on HN

> And it turns out that the German soldiers faced surprisingly mild consequences for disobeying unlawful orders.

Huh. Franz Jägerstätter was executed for refusing to fight in the war.


Replies

hamandcheeseyesterday at 1:10 PM

Franz Jägerstätter was not a soldier.

show 1 reply
the_afyesterday at 2:19 PM

There are many documented and studied cases where orders to carry out massacres which were disobeyed carried no harm to the German who refused.

Mostly demotion or transfer to a different area, but no execution or jail time. Sometimes not even that.

I'm talking about not taking part in massacres (e.g. shooting unarmed women and children, locking people in a barn and setting it on fire, etc), not about refusing to fight, cowardice, aiding the enemy or actual treason.