alt Hacker NewsHow would you compare it with Node Red?
I've just poked at them, but my impression was that Node Red much more capable.
IIRC one of my issues with n8n was the lack of streaming ability, which kills it for large datasets.
Replies
Have not used Node Red in production and only played with it briefly, but n8n is more of a Zapier replacement whereas Node Red I believe is more of an IoT automation platform.
n8n is made so that you can set it up and give your staff access and they can manage their own workflows (like "when a customer opens a support ticket, update their Salesforce record to increment the number of tickets they have opened").
It's clearly aimed at non technical users being able to develop their own solutions to problems (for better or for worse), more so than Windmill which is made for developers to solve their own problems or develop solutions that non-technical people can use. Node Red if I remember correctly is more heavily weighted toward real time events for dev (especially hardware/IoT dev) use than "let the support team manage their own workflows for routing customer complaints"
My approach to using Node-RED for AI has been to build re-usable sub flows with high-level functionality (parser, chunker, etc.).
You can go a _long_ way with the split/join nodes and a little ingenuity to work around any issues with streaming.
I've used Node Red and n8n both on my homelab and deleted Node Red after awhile. The UI, workflow and 3rd party service support is simply just better on n8n. I could see Node Red having its advantages if you're used to writing code all day (I'm not).
I evaluated both at one point, and n8n is a "we have NodeRed at home" product. Didn't see the point.
For doing streaming in Node-RED, I created a library[1] - it's been through exacatly one example flow[2] - for that it worked well. I've not had a use case for it, it was just an idea of mine to implement an ETL pipeline using NodeRED.
The library just uses the streaming API[3] of NodeJS - effectively converting lines of CSV (for example) into individual messages that flow through NodeRED.
NodeRED isn't great for handling large messages but perfect for directing many small messages.
[1] https://flows.nodered.org/node/@gregoriusrippenstein/node-re...
[2] https://flowhub.org/f/c520d9da20ad7f1d
[3] https://nodejs.org/dist/latest-v18.x/docs/api/stream.html