logoalt Hacker News

breppp05/03/20252 repliesview on HN

Bullshit Jobs, both the article and the subsequent book explore this theme a lot

https://libcom.org/article/phenomenon-bullshit-jobs-david-gr...


Replies

rcxdude05/04/2025

I think this idea generally doesn't bear out, at least as described in the book. For the most part, the kinds of jobs that are potentially actually mostly bullshit, are generally not considered it by those who do them, while those that he would characterise as just "shit jobs" will generally have a high percentage of percieved bullshit by those who work them.

I am amenable to the idea that there is a lot of wasted pointless work, but not to the idea that there's some kayfabe arrangement where everyone involved thinks it's pointless but pretends otherwise, I think generally most people around such work have actually convinced themselves it's important.

PeterStuer05/03/2025

Read the article. The book is just a long boring elongation without new content.

show 1 reply