logoalt Hacker News

maxericksonyesterday at 3:44 PM3 repliesview on HN

What sort of regulation do you think should apply to germ line editing to inactivate a particular gene?

Like is a blanket ban the only reasonable approach?


Replies

WhatIsDukkhayesterday at 4:16 PM

European consumers seem to not want factory farms that produce such low quality food that it needs to be CRISPRed (as is the case with this story) just to be kept alive long enough.

I also am in that camp, I don't want to eat pork raised in unsanitary conditions and then sold to me at top dollar (because lying/obscuring about sourcing).

show 1 reply
Natsuyesterday at 4:02 PM

This seems to be a small edit to a single receptor to keep pigs from getting a particular disease by not allowing the virus to enter their cells. It's hard to see how helping pigs stay healthy could have a negative impact on human health, but a lot of people are against eating things that are 'unnatural' in any sense.

show 5 replies
paganelyesterday at 4:59 PM

> Like is a blanket ban the only reasonable approach?

From my pov as a fellow EU citizen a blanket ban for this kind of creepy stuff is the only viable option. Let the Americans become Frankesteins for all I care, it’s their choice, all in the name of “science”.

show 2 replies