logoalt Hacker News

hinkleyyesterday at 10:40 PM4 repliesview on HN

Do you want traffic circles? Because this is how you get traffic circles.

(I used to live in a neighborhood full of them and I liked them but very many people disagreed with me. If you make speed bumps not work then they will all be replaced with slaloms or circles.


Replies

DecentShoesyesterday at 10:43 PM

I had to look up what a traffic circle is, but apparently it just means roundabout. And yes, I do want roundabouts, who wouldn't?

Is there any serious argument against them? I've heard they aren't common in America.

show 5 replies
furyofantarestoday at 2:17 AM

I'm confused, all of the traffic circles I drive through were just intersections before, no speed bumps. And all of the speed bumps I encounter are in parking lots, and can't be replaced by a traffic circle.

Are there traffic circles that are primarily about slowing traffic rather than managing intersections?

show 2 replies
vemomtoday at 12:11 AM

Yes I dream of them. Just imagine cars at 4 way intersection all being able to move!

dmixyesterday at 10:46 PM

I doubt most cars will be jacked up high off the ground like in the video, especially to fully handle speed bumps at higher speeds. There will be tradeoffs in such a thing.

IRL this is probably just handles small bumps and turns comfortably thing.