logoalt Hacker News

WalterBrightyesterday at 12:16 AM1 replyview on HN

The Sovied Union and Communist China all had vast natural resources. But a third world economy.

Japan, S Korea and Hong Kong have next to no natural resources. Great prosperity.

Germany turned to free markets after WW2 and enjoyed the "German Miracle". (Germany has since turned to socialism, with predictable results.) Germany received far, far less Marshall Plan money than Britain and France, who had no miracle.

> but to say it's the only unique thing about America is just wrong

History shows otherwise.


Replies

dehuggeryesterday at 3:49 AM

Consider, for a moment, the state that China was in at the conclusion of WW2. It hadn't even industrialized yet. The British and the Japanese absolutely trashed China for over a hundred years!

Russia was also not industrialized until after their revolution in ~1920, and suffered horrific losses in the homeland during WW2.

The US emerged from WW2 fully industrialized and nearly unscathed. The US mainland remained untouched throughout both world wars.

The starting positions were far from equal. You attribute too much to free markets.

show 2 replies