logoalt Hacker News

WalterBrightyesterday at 3:34 AM2 repliesview on HN

During the 19th century, the US elevated scores of millions of immigrants from poverty to the middle class and beyond. The newly wealthy "aristocracy" sprang from the poor, much to the disdain of European royalty.

Poverty in the US continued going down until 1968, when it began edging up again. 1968 was the advent of the "Great Society" programs.


Replies

mmoossyesterday at 5:42 AM

The current wealth disparity, at historic levels, began growing mostly in the 1980s.

> 1968 was the advent of the "Great Society" programs.

1968 was when Nixon was elected.

> During the 19th century, the US elevated scores of millions of immigrants from poverty to the middle class and beyond. The newly wealthy "aristocracy" sprang from the poor

I don't grasp the relevance of these 19th century events to today. How does it address the fact that today, for most of the population, US outcomes are worse than many peer countries?

Who are you quoting with "aristocracy" and did they really come from poor people or from the middle class?

show 1 reply
ajrossyesterday at 10:06 AM

> Poverty in the US continued going down until 1968, when it began edging up again. 1968 was the advent of the "Great Society" programs.

Poverty rates are significantly lower in the industrial world outside the US, even (especially!) in the "socialist" countries you seem to liken to LBJ policies. Seems like the same data you're referring to above cuts directly and strongly against this point.