logoalt Hacker News

hnlmorgtoday at 8:36 AM2 repliesview on HN

Back when Bluetooth was new, the alternative for wirelessly sharing data between mobile devices like phones was infrared.

IR was exceptionally slow, required line-of-sight and even at the time, felt like a shitty solution. So even though the early implementations of Bluetooth also left a lot to be desired (battery hungry, insecure, and also slow), it was still a massive improvement on what came before.

Wireless USB wasn’t a significant enough improvement to Bluetooth given that BT was already ubiquitous by that point, but also cheap and (by that point) battery efficient now too.


Replies

m4rtinktoday at 9:33 AM

IR with palm devices was super nice - just point to the other device and send, then confirm on the other. No persistent pairing bullshit & you could also use it to control TVs.

show 1 reply
adrianNtoday at 9:59 AM

I wonder why IR is slow. Shouldn’t there be plenty of bandwidth available at those frequencies?

show 5 replies