logoalt Hacker News

chfritz05/04/20253 repliesview on HN

Love the idea. However, there is no guarantee that the no-upload will not change. Which begs a question: wouldn't it be great if browsers provided a guaranteed "offline only" mode? Since they don't, I personally would prefer downloading this app as a standalone electron (or similar) app, or a docker container where I could disable Internet access.


Replies

ironmanszombie05/04/2025

It's a great idea indeed. But the paranoid _like myself?_ would probably not recommend it as it runs on...well...a browser. I'm not at ease with the chance that a code change someday would / could allow a copy of my file to be uploaded anywhere.

As for having the browsers run in "offline mode" (proxy equal 127.0.0 1?)...neat but I would vote against it. My fridge just needs to keep stuff cold, my toaster should serve bread, my Internet browser should not be an app.

philjohnson05/04/2025

Thanks!

The "offline only" app could be a PWA where you can access if if you're offline but I could even enforce disabling network requests in the code itself. Seems like the most straightforward solution to me. Could even make updates opt-in. Would keep it lightweight and easily accessible for anyone.

What do you think of this? Would you be willing to pay for this, or are certain features you'd be willing to pay for? Curious you're thoughts.

reyqn05/04/2025

You could use firefox containers to redirect a tab to localhost.