logoalt Hacker News

mongoltoday at 7:38 AM7 repliesview on HN

But how would that work for news reporting? Imagine a politician doing something stupid in public. Should it not be possible to broadcast that if he disallows it?


Replies

smoetoday at 10:37 AM

In Switzerland, where people have the legal right to control whether and how their image may be photographed and published, exemptions are made if the image/person is of public interest. This is decided on a case-by-case basis, so the news org has to be willing to argue this in court.

Let's say, as an example, a married politician having an affair with someone. Generally, news sites will publish photos with the face of the politician visible but would blur the other person. The former is clearly a person of public interest, the latter is not. Even if it's a photo taken in a public space.

show 1 reply
sjducbtoday at 1:56 PM

This isn’t about real photos of things that actually happened. This is about AI generated imagery.

So it’s not a photo of a politician doing something bad. It’s an AI recreation of what they are alleged to have done.

The law does have to be written very carefully.

show 1 reply
rsynnotttoday at 7:42 AM

Would likely fall under fair use or an analogous right in most places. If Coca-cola does something stupid, they do not have the ability to censor depictions of their logo from reporting on it.

show 1 reply
impossibleforktoday at 8:49 AM

Think of that like reproducing a particularly ill-conceived Coca Cola advertisement.

Then, when someone uses their face to promote something, someone else can repeat the face with what it promotes.

So I think the whole thing actually works in this particular case.

nashashmitoday at 9:53 AM

That could come under fair use. Like if you had a coke can on film, you could broadcast it. But you could not apply the coke brand on some other product.

xboxnolifestoday at 7:56 AM

It works the same way as news currently does. You can report on people, but you can't take a picture of someone and use it as your brand's model/logo.

show 2 replies