logoalt Hacker News

mytailorisrichyesterday at 2:35 PM2 repliesview on HN

But that's exactly how the EU works. If you give the "wrong" answer they'll keep going until you give the "right" answer.

France and the Netherlands rejected the proposed EU constitution... nevermind, the same was in the later Lisbon treaty.

Ireland rejected the Nice and Lisbon treaties... nevermind they still passed when asked again after cosmetic changes and "information campaigns".

Poland voted for the wrong government... EU suspended funds until they voted for the right government at the next election.


Replies

epolanskiyesterday at 3:02 PM

> Poland voted for the wrong government... EU suspended funds until they voted for the right government at the next election.

I am polish, please *do not spread falsehood*.

EU funds suspension came because of Polish non-compliance with several EU laws.

Most notably the previous government had created a "new" government-controlled chamber of judgement that gave de facto the executive branch control over the judicial one.

Judges in Poland could be suspended and punished if politicians didn't like their rulings. Not only that, judges could be suspended, fined and even jailed over any public comment.

This created a situation where essentially judges where promoted, punished or cherry picked according to how aligned they were to the ruling party.

This was a blatant violation of Polish constitution as well as the treaties Poland itself signed when joining the EU.

show 1 reply
darkwateryesterday at 2:49 PM

> Poland voted for the wrong government... EU suspended funds until they voted for the right government at the next election.

On the other end there is the "don't interfere with anything" and you get totalitarianism as a side effect, eventually. If a democratically elected government passes a law that makes killing some category of people lawful, should they be allowed to do it?

show 1 reply