logoalt Hacker News

kjkjadksjtoday at 3:25 AM5 repliesview on HN

Banning campaigning would go a long way. The state already mails out voter information containing a little stump speech of each registered candidate at least for Californian elections. Further advertisement is purely propaganda and leads to establishment victories over merit and a genuinely attractive platform.


Replies

ch4s3today at 4:33 AM

File this under Lies Engineers Believe About Political Science.

show 2 replies
SpicyLemonZesttoday at 3:40 AM

Are stump speeches not propaganda? I don't see why the election system should privilege candidates whose political views are most compellingly expressed in quick little text blurbs.

show 1 reply
roenxitoday at 3:25 AM

> Banning campaigning would go a long way.

With tongue in cheek, that qualifies you as the "people like Stalin" category. Not a good idea.

TFYStoday at 6:52 AM

I don't think that would do much in the current environment of media consolidation. Instead of direct campaigns we'd just see the issues of some candidates be more present in the media. Trumps stump says that illegal immigrants are the cause of all our issues and the media will be full of crimes by illegal immigrants, etc.

jahewsontoday at 4:12 AM

Being able to give a good speech is merit when the goal is to select a leader.

show 3 replies