logoalt Hacker News

frumplestlatzlast Friday at 6:44 PM1 replyview on HN

it’s a weird problem, in that (1) DNS is hard, and (2) you really need the upstream vendor to solve the problem, because correct applications want to use the system resolver.

If you don’t use the system resolver, you have to glue into the system’s configuration mechanism for resolvers somehow … which isn’t simple — for example, there’s a lot of complex logic on macOS around handling which resolver to use based on what connections, VPNs, etc, are present.

And the there’s nsswitch and other plugin systems that are meant to allow globally configured hooks plug into the name resolution path.


Replies

AndyKelleylast Friday at 8:07 PM

(1) DNS is hard

It's really not.

Just because some systems took something fundamentally simple and wrapped a bunch of unnecessary complexity around it does not make it hard.

At its core, it's an elegant, minimal protocol.

show 3 replies