logoalt Hacker News

dav-last Friday at 10:58 PM4 repliesview on HN

What does this have to do with executive orders?


Replies

alwalast Friday at 11:04 PM

I imagine it’s a nod to the way the stated goal would normally be pursued, but in this case is not.

It sounds like a good idea to establish a uniform national policy! And the federal government can do that (although only for the very specific purposes spelled out in the Constitution). The right way to do that is to pass a law through both houses of Congress, and the president to sign it into law. Maybe the law even specifies a broad framework and authorizes the executive branch to dial in the specific details (although the court seems to be souring on that kind of thing too).

The god-king proclaiming a brand new framework governing a major new sector of the economy To Be So is.. not the normal way

peterlklast Friday at 11:05 PM

The link is highly relevant to the executive order because this executive order attempts to place limitations on what laws US states can create.

show 2 replies
treetalkerlast Friday at 11:43 PM

peterlk and lesuorac nail it: the EO purports to preempt state law, but EOs aren't law and that's not how preemption works.

ang_cirelast Saturday at 7:56 AM

Probably something to do with the section titled:

> Sec. 7. *Preemption of State Laws* Mandating Deceptive Conduct in AI Models.