logoalt Hacker News

kaikailast Saturday at 10:08 AM3 repliesview on HN

Digging a hole and filling it up might very well have value as an art piece. The process is important for art, not just the end product.


Replies

Wowfunhappylast Saturday at 11:12 AM

Okay. Let's say we find out tomorrow that Spirited Away was animated via generative AI. Unbeknownst to everyone, Ghibli has a top-secret AI division which—thanks to some key lucky breakthroughs—is many decades ahead of everyone else and has been for a long time. The animators are a front to hide the truth; Miyazaki's anti-AI declarations were pure jealousy.

Would Spirited Away no longer be a good film?

show 2 replies
spencerflemlast Saturday at 10:16 AM

And at the very least, if someone was willing to do back breaking labor to tell me something, it’s probably something they think is important

richardfuloplast Saturday at 1:23 PM

the process is not important for art, although it might have value for people. art is a subjective experience, one that comes to life in the obeserver.