logoalt Hacker News

torginusyesterday at 4:58 PM8 repliesview on HN

Man, the Chinese government must be a bunch of saints that you must go back 35 years to dig up something heinous that they did.


Replies

itsyonasyesterday at 5:08 PM

This suggests that the Chinese government recognises that its legitimacy is conditional and potentially unstable. Consequently, the state treats uncontrolled public discourse as a direct threat. By contrast, countries such as the United States can tolerate the public exposure of war crimes, illegal actions or state violence, since such revelations rarely result in any significant consequences. While public outrage may influence narratives or elections to some extent, it does not fundamentally endanger the continuity of power.

I am not sure if one approach is necessarily worse than the other.

show 2 replies
spankaleeyesterday at 4:59 PM

Are you actually defending the censorship of Tiananmen Square?

show 1 reply
diego_sandovalyesterday at 6:35 PM

You don't need to go that far back

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_internment_camps

poszlemyesterday at 5:48 PM

The current heinous thing they do is censorship. Your comment would be relevant if the OP had to find an example of censorship from 35 years ago, but all he had to do today was to ask the model a question.

nonethewiseryesterday at 6:08 PM

Which other party that is still ruling today (aka dictatorship) mass murdered a bunch of students within the past 35 years? Or equivalent.

show 1 reply
quietsegfaultyesterday at 5:41 PM

1. Xinjiang detention and surveillance (2017-ongoing)

2. Hong Kong National Security Law (2020-ongoing)

3. COVID-19 lockdown policies (2020-2022)

4. Crackdown on journalists and dissidents (ongoing)

5. Tibet cultural suppression (ongoing)

6. Forced organ harvesting allegations (ongoing)

7. South China Sea militarization (ongoing)

8. Taiwan military intimidation (2020-ongoing)

9. Suppression of Inner Mongolia language rights (2020-ongoing)

10. Transnational repression (2020-ongoing)

show 1 reply
WarmWashyesterday at 5:39 PM

Tiananmen Square is a simple test that most people recognize.

I'm sure the model will get cold feet talking about the Hong Kong protests and uyghur persecution as well.

show 1 reply
yoz-yyesterday at 4:59 PM

To my knowledge this model is not 35 years old.