logoalt Hacker News

bleepblaptoday at 5:16 AM5 repliesview on HN

there is actually a science change that happened, and it's not (entirely) just politicians changing their mind.

The big thing going from X-ray (2d) to CT (spin an X-ray machine around and take a ton of pictures to recreate a 3d image) did a lot to let security people see inside of a bag, but the hitch is that if you see a blob of gray is that water, shampoo or something else?

The recent advance that is letting this happen is machines who will send multiple wavelengths of X-ray through the material: since different materials absorb light differently, your machine can distinguish between materials, which lets you be more sure that that 2litre is (mostly) water, and then they can discriminate


Replies

NL807today at 12:16 PM

These machines don't really detect what kind of materials stuff is composed of, much of that is just a crude classification based on density. True identification requires broadband x-rays emission with spectral analysis.

show 1 reply
bleepblaptoday at 5:33 AM

There's a whole ton of people taking about MRI -- MRIs are a completely universe than CT/X-rays

show 1 reply
dingdongditchmetoday at 9:31 AM

it has been such a godsend flying out of Frankfurt where they have the new scanners and you don't have to empty out your bag anymore. So much smoother. Then I fly back and get all annoyed at the other airports. I was told Oslo airport is holding out until it becomes regulation to use the new scanners. Security-Theater is still what it is. It is super weak imho, despite never having seriously attempted a heist or trying to get contraband on a plane. I miss the good old days where you handed your luggage to a guy just before boarding the plane.

show 2 replies
5d41402abc4btoday at 8:22 AM

Can this X Ray bit flip memory or damage NAND?

show 3 replies
HNisCIStoday at 5:36 AM

Dual energy x ray has been around forever though, like decades.

show 1 reply