logoalt Hacker News

cootsnucklast Wednesday at 5:46 PM2 repliesview on HN

The error rate for human transcription can be as high as 5%.


Replies

qingcharleslast Wednesday at 11:38 PM

I did transcription for a while in 2021. It is absurdly hard. Especially as these days humans only get the difficult jobs that AI has already taken a stab at.

The hardest one I did was for a sports network where it was a motorcross motorbike event where most of what you could hear was the roar of the bikes. There were two commentators I had to transcribe over the top of that mess and they were using the slang insider nicknames for all the riders, not their published names, so I had to sit and Google forums to find the names of the riders while I was listening. I'm not even sure how these local models would even be able to handle that insanity at all because they almost certainly lack enough domain knowledge.

XCSmelast Wednesday at 5:53 PM

Oh wow, I thought humans are like 0.1% error rate, if they are native speakers and aware of the subject being discussed.

show 3 replies