logoalt Hacker News

puppymasteryesterday at 5:55 AM5 repliesview on HN

Regardless of how Apple will solve this, please just solve it. Siri is borderline useless these days.

> Will it rain today? Please unlock your iphone for that

> Any new messages from Chris? You will need to unlock your iphone for that

> Please play youtube music Playing youtube music... please open youtube music app to do that

All settings and permission granted. Utterly painful.


Replies

bgentryyesterday at 4:34 PM

You'll need to unlock your iPhone first. Even though you're staring at the screen and just asked me to do something, and you saw the unlocked icon at the top of your screen before/while triggering me, please continue staring at this message for at least 5 seconds before I actually attempt FaceID to unlock your phone to do what you asked.

schnableyesterday at 4:16 PM

I think half your examples are made up, or not Apple's fault, but it sounds like what you really want is to disable your passcode.

show 2 replies
blksyesterday at 9:12 AM

Do you want people being able to command your phone without unblocking? Maybe what you want is to disable phone blocking all together

show 2 replies
KaiserProyesterday at 9:32 AM

Right, but you understand why allowing access to unauthenticated voice is bad for security right?

show 1 reply
ramses0yesterday at 2:40 PM

re: youtube music, I just tried it on my phone and it worked fine... maaaybe b/c you're not a youtube premium subscriber and google wants to shove ads into your sweet sweet eyeballs?

The one that kindof caught me off guard was asking "hey siri, how long will it take me to get home?" => "You'll need to unlock your iPhone for that, but I don't recommend doing that while driving..." => if you left your phone unattended at a bar and someone could figure out your home address w/o unlock.

...I'm kindof with you, maybe similar to AirTags and "Trusted Locations" there could be a middle ground of "don't worry about exposing rough geolocation or summary PII". At home, in your car (connected to a known CarPlay), kindof an in-between "Geo-Unlock"?

show 1 reply