logoalt Hacker News

legitsteryesterday at 6:05 PM5 repliesview on HN

I'm still not sure I understand Anthropic's general strategy right now.

They are doing these broad marketing programs trying to take on ChatGPT for "normies". And yet their bread and butter is still clearly coding.

Meanwhile, Claude's general use cases are... fine. For generic research topics, I find that ChatGPT and Gemini run circles around it: in the depth of research, the type of tasks it can handle, and the quality and presentation of the responses.

Anthropic is also doing all of these goofy things to try to establish the "humanity" of their chatbot - giving it rights and a constitution and all that. Yet it weirdly feels the most transactional out of all of them.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a paying Claude customer and love what it's good at. I just think there's a disconnect between what Claude is and what their marketing department thinks it is.


Replies

tgtweakyesterday at 6:09 PM

Claude itself (outside of code workflows) actually works very well for general purpose chat. I have a few non-technical friends that have moved over from chatgpt after some side-by-side testing and I've yet to see one go back - which is good since claude circa 8 months ago was borderline unusable for anything but coding on the api.

redox99today at 12:33 AM

Why would I even use Claude for asking something on their web, considering that chips away my claude code usage limit?

Their limit system is so bad.

eaf7e281yesterday at 6:16 PM

I kinda agree. Their model just doesn't feel "daily" enough. I would use it for any "agentic" tasks and for using tools, but definitely not for day to day questions.

show 3 replies
Squarexyesterday at 8:59 PM

Claude sucks at non English languages. Gemini and ChatGPT are much better. Grok is the worst. I am a native Czech speaker and Claude makes up words and Grok sometimes respond in Russian. So while I love it for coding, it’s unusable for general purpose for me.

show 3 replies
derwikitoday at 12:14 AM

It feels very similar to how Lyft positioned themselves against Uber. (And we know how that played out)