logoalt Hacker News

elzbardicoyesterday at 6:37 PM1 replyview on HN

Trusting domain experts is precisely what I like in Britannica. I want an environment where real domain experts are not drowned by a mob of midwits.


Replies

crumpledyesterday at 7:27 PM

Arguably, you get more and better domain experts in Wikipedia. I have a set of Britannicas, it's severely lacking in citations and definitely out of date, no matter how new.

The question of article quality has been studied from the very beginning. Wikipedia almost always wins.