logoalt Hacker News

stego-techyesterday at 1:51 PM5 repliesview on HN

This is another facet of the fierce opposition to AI by a swath of the population: it’s quite literally destroying the last bit of enjoyment we could wring from existence in the form of hobbies funded through normal employment.

Think of the PC gamers, who first dealt with COVID supply shocks, followed by crypto making GPUs scarce and untenable, then GPU makers raising prices and narrowing inventory to only the highest-end SKUs, only to outright abandon them entirely for AI - which then also consumed their RAM and SSDs. A hobby that used to be enjoyed by folks on even a modest budget is now a theft risk given the insane resale priced of parts on the second-hand market due to scarcity.

And that extends to others as well. The swaths of folks who made freelance or commission artistry work through Patreons and conventions and the like are suddenly struggling as customers and companies spew out AI slop using their work and without compensation. Tech workers, previously the wealthy patron of artisans and communities, are now being laid off en masse for AI CapEx buildouts and share pumps as investors get cold feet about what these systems are actually doing to the economy at large (definite bad, questionable good, uncertain futures).

Late stage capitalism’s sole respite was consumerism, and we can’t even do that anymore thanks to AI gobbling up all the resources and capital. It’s no wonder people are pissed at AI boosters trying to say this is a miracle technology that’ll lift everyone up: it’s already kicking people down, and nobody actually wants to admit or address that lest their investments be disrupted to protect humans.


Replies

9devyesterday at 2:12 PM

I think this started a lot earlier actually. A few generations back, many people played an instrument, or at least could sing. It didn't matter that none of them was a Mozart, because they didn't had to be. For making music or singing together in a family or a friend group, it was wholly sufficient to be just good, not necessarily great.

But when everyone has access to recordings of the world's best musicians at all times, why listen to uncle Harry's shoddy guitar play? Why sing Christmas songs together when you can put on the Sinatra Christmas jazz playlist on Spotify?

show 4 replies
zozbot234yesterday at 9:57 PM

This is all temporary scarcity. GPUs becoming scarce and expensive today is exactly what we want to make future GPUs (and other electronics) cheap and abundant tomorrow. This is what happens when any capital intensive industry runs into a capacity ceiling it needs to push through.

simianwordsyesterday at 6:42 PM

Apologies for being glib but I never thought I’d see a sincere “think of the gamers” comment.

Your whole post is a bit vague and naive. If people enjoyed real art more than AI art, then the market will decide it. If they don’t then we should not be making people enjoy what they don’t.

show 2 replies
WillPostForFoodyesterday at 6:42 PM

Think of the PC gamers

The battlecry of the new revolution?

show 1 reply
dehrmannyesterday at 8:47 PM

> PC gamers

There's a pretty deep back catalog of PC games that will run on integrated GPUs.

> The swaths of folks who made freelance or commission artistry...

Those are people turning their hobby into a side hustle. If it's a hustle they depend on, this sucks. If it's actually a hobby, meh. You're drawing for you. Who cares if AI can also do it.

show 1 reply