logoalt Hacker News

pfdietzyesterday at 9:13 PM3 repliesview on HN

At some point physics entitlement has to end -- why not here? We can't just keep scaling up the size and cost of fundamental physics experiments. Eventually the cost becomes so large that platitudinous arguments for them don't work.


Replies

mmoossyesterday at 10:52 PM

How can you look at current and recent US science and call it 'entitlement'? Have there been larger cuts anywhere in modern history?

show 1 reply
Izikiel43yesterday at 10:17 PM

It's not a question of "can", it's a question of "should". No one knows what discoveries can happen and what the spillover from them could be in the future. In essence, it's a bet, a moonshot.

micromacrofootyesterday at 9:40 PM

We absolutely can, and I reckon we will... this is like a fraction of a percent of science funding which is a fraction of a percent of GDP, we spend more on maintaining warheads we can't use

10% of the US military budget for one year could build a 100km collider, RHIC is 4km

show 1 reply