logoalt Hacker News

libraryofbabelyesterday at 5:29 PM1 replyview on HN

Slightly tangential, but I discovered recently that the famous literary critic Harold Bloom was a huge fan of Ursula Le Guin and rated her one of the great canonical writers of the 20th century, in all of literature not just sci-fi. Also, they never met but they struck up a polite friendship over email when they were both old and chatted back and forth.

Some might consider this raises the stature of Ursula Le Guin. I consider it rather as raising the stature of Harold Bloom. He recognized how she transcended genre and belongs alongside (or perhaps, above) writers of highbrow literary fiction.


Replies

ilamontyesterday at 6:41 PM

> He recognized how she transcended genre and belongs alongside (or perhaps, above) writers of highbrow literary fiction.

In the 70s and 80s, Le Guin and other SFF authors were very aware of the literary divide that often regarded most science fiction and fantasy as little better than pulp fiction. Gene Wolfe's essays and speeches in Castle of Days touch on this several times.

What changed was the arrival of a new generation of literary critics, researchers, and readers who knew greatness in some of the SFF works of the era.