logoalt Hacker News

pkulakyesterday at 6:11 PM3 repliesview on HN

If this is “on par” with LFP energy density, I’m not sure there’s any need for LFP now. Sodium ion seems to thoroughly beat it in every other metric.


Replies

loegyesterday at 6:41 PM

On par on a per kg basis, but is it on par on a volume basis? If it takes up more space, that might pose packaging challenges relative to LFP.

show 2 replies
adrian_byesterday at 7:22 PM

I have no idea about the characteristics of these new sodium-ion batteries, but there is a great likelihood that they auto-discharge much faster than LFP batteries.

This means that if you do not use the car for some time, you may need to recharge it before you can use it again. This may be a problem if the car is left far from a charger.

Otherwise I agree with what you said.

woeiruayesterday at 6:32 PM

I haven’t seen any info on charging speed. Can you recharge these as quickly as LFP?

show 1 reply