logoalt Hacker News

PaulHouleyesterday at 7:28 PM2 repliesview on HN

With the odd story that we paid the price for it in the long term.

This book

https://www.amazon.com/Zero-Sum-Society-Distribution-Possibi...

tells the compelling story that the Mellon family teamed up with the steelworker's union to use protectionism to protect the American steel industry's investments in obsolete open hearth steel furnaces that couldn't compete on a fair market with the basic oxygen furnace process adopted by countries that had their obsolete furnaces blown up. The rest of US industry, such as our car industry, were dragged down by this because they were using expensive and inferior materials. I think this book had a huge impact in terms of convincing policymakers everywhere that tariffs are bad.

Funny the Mellon family went on to further political mischief

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Mellon_Scaife#Oppositi...


Replies

vonduryesterday at 7:37 PM

Ha, we gutted our manufacturing base, so if we bring it back it will now be state of the art! Not sure if that will work out for us, but hey their is some precedence.

show 2 replies
hansvmyesterday at 10:33 PM

I'll take a look at that story later. I'm curious though, why is US metallurgy consistently top-notch if the processes are inferior? When I use wrenches, bicycle frames, etc from most other countries I have no end of troubles with weld delamination, stress fractures compounding into catastrophic failures, and whatnot, even including enormous wrenches just snapping in half with forces far below what something a tenth the size with American steel could handle.

show 2 replies