logoalt Hacker News

FranklinJabaryesterday at 9:42 AM5 repliesview on HN

Owning land. Whoever came up with this idea needs to be hung and revived a million times, and then tortured to death a million more. Our society has been mutilated as a result.

I think you could ascribe this to either NIMBY or YIMBY harebrained thinking. We need a third option that's pro-human.

We need public fucking housing.


Replies

zajio1amyesterday at 3:44 PM

Most of NIMBY legislature and processes that block private construction also block public construction. So most YIMBY arguments to improve the situation apply to both public and private constructions. (Not to mention that public construction has a plenty of problems specific to it.)

energy123yesterday at 10:41 AM

There is no trade-off or contradiction between public housing and YIMBY deregulation to allow more private development. I want both. They are complementary.

There's also overlap between YIMBYs are Georgists, they share some skepticism around private land ownership.

show 1 reply
roenxiyesterday at 10:26 AM

You seem fairly keen on building public housing. Wouldn't that qualify you as a YIMBY? The YIMBYs are the lobby that tends to be pro-new-buildings.

If you want to build public housing, only the NIMBYs would really oppose the idea.

show 1 reply
Nasrudithyesterday at 12:36 PM

We get it, you're a commie. No need to constantly repeat that you want public versions of everything that already exists.

s5300yesterday at 8:34 PM

[dead]