logoalt Hacker News

emil-lpyesterday at 7:42 PM4 repliesview on HN

"GPT did this". Authored by Guevara (Institute for Advanced Study), Lupsasca (Vanderbilt University), Skinner (University of Cambridge), and Strominger (Harvard University).

Probably not something that the average GI Joe would be able to prompt their way to...

I am skeptical until they show the chat log leading up to the conjecture and proof.


Replies

Sharlinyesterday at 8:07 PM

I'm a big LLM sceptic but that's… moving the goalposts a little too far. How could an average Joe even understand the conjecture enough to write the initial prompt? Or do you mean that experts would give him the prompt to copy-paste, and hope that the proverbial monkey can come up with a Henry V? At the very least posit someone like a grad student in particle physics as the human user.

show 3 replies
jmalickiyesterday at 9:38 PM

"Grad Student did this". Co-authored by <Famous advisor 1>, <Famous advisor 2>, <Famous advisor 3>.

Is this so different?

hgfdayesterday at 8:38 PM

[dead]

famouswafflesyesterday at 7:48 PM

The paper has all those prominent institutions who acknowledge the contribution so realistically, why would you be skeptical ?

show 2 replies