logoalt Hacker News

sodapopcanyesterday at 4:53 AM1 replyview on HN

Even though it means I probably wouldn't have a job, I think about this a lot and agree that it should. Nowadays suggesting programmers should be highly knowledgeable at what they do will get you called a gatekeeper.


Replies

moron4hireyesterday at 1:54 PM

While it is literally gatekeeping, it's necessary. Doctors, architects, lawyers should be gatekept.

I used to work on industrial lifting crane simulation software. People used it to plan out how to perform big lift jobs to make sure they were safe. Literal, "if we fuck this up, people could die" levels of responsibility. All the qualification I had was my BS in CS and two years of experience. It was lucky circumstance that I was actually quiet good at math and physics to be able to discover that there were major errors in the physics model.

Not every programmer is going to encounter issues like that, but also, neither can we predict where things will end up. Not every lawyer is going to be a criminal defense lawyer. Not every doctor is going to be a brain surgeon. Not every architect is going to design skyscrapers. But they all do work that needs to be warranteed in some way.

We're already seeing people getting killed because of AI. Brian in middle management "getting to code again" is not a good enough reason.