logoalt Hacker News

IshKebabyesterday at 6:08 PM2 repliesview on HN

In fact I'll go further - in my experience people with a software background make much better hardware designers than people with an EE background because they are aware of modern software best practices. Many hardware designers are happy to hack whatever together with duck tape and glue. As a result most of the hardware industry is decades behind the software industry in many ways, e.g. still relying on hacky Perl and TCL scripts to cobble things together.

The notable exceptions are:

* Formal verification, which is very widely used in hardware and barely used in software (not software's fault really - there are good reasons for it).

* What the software guys now call "deterministic system testing", which is just called "testing" in the hardware world because that's how it has always been done.


Replies

general1465yesterday at 6:49 PM

> in my experience people with a software background make much better hardware designers than people with an EE background because they are aware of modern software best practices.

I know them. Especially older folks. Ramming all parts on one huge sheet instead of separation by function. Refusing to use buses. Refusing to insert part numbers into schematics so they can just export BoM directly and writing BoM by hand instead.

Watching these guys is like watching lowest office worker inserting values from Excel into calculator so he can then write the result into same Excel table.

show 1 reply
EdNuttingyesterday at 7:37 PM

Side note: Formal theorem proving is even more rare than formal model checking..!