logoalt Hacker News

TZubiriyesterday at 7:47 PM1 replyview on HN

>and at the federal level, the legal liability is on the person who posts it, not who hosts the tool. this was a mistake that will likely be corrected over the next six years

[citation needed]

Historically hosts have always absolutely been responsible for the materials they host, see DMCA law, CSAM case law...


Replies

parl_matchyesterday at 8:07 PM

no offense but you completely misinterpreted what i wrote. i didnt say who hosts the materials, i said who hosts the tool. i didnt mention anything about the platform, which is a very relevant but separate party.

if you think i said otherwise, please quote me, thank you.

> Historically hosts have always absolutely been responsible for the materials they host,

[citation needed] :) go read up on section 230.

for example with dmca, liability arises if the host acts in bad faith, generates the infringing content itself, or fails to act on a takedown notice

that is quite some distance from "always absolutely". in fact, it's the whole point of 230

show 1 reply