logoalt Hacker News

ashton314yesterday at 10:26 PM1 replyview on HN

> Around 20 non-fiction and technical books in about 15 years

That's not lot, mate. Maybe more than the average American unfortunately, but I consider a year where I get through 2–3 books a slow one. And that's just reading I do outside of my job. What matters, of course, is both the quality and quantity of what you read. The short of it is, your attempt at building your ethos has fallen pretty flat here.

> AI is going to disrupt the whole academia [sic]

Yes, it has and it continues to. I'm not arguing against that. Joe Liemandt said that "all educational content is obsolete", which presumably includes not only textbooks like SICP or Sipser's Introduction to the Theory of Computation (just listing some CS textbooks because I'm in CS) but also great works of literature and philosophy that are important texts like The Odyssey or A Tale of Two Cities. If he meant to exclude such texts from the umbrella of "all educational content", well, then that's telling too. :)

> …it is infinitely better than a book or a teacher.

Maybe for someone who struggles with literacy or who hasn't had the pleasure of a good teacher. If you really believe this I'd like to see you try to substantiate your claim.

> The student could move at his/her own pace…

The article is about a grade school kids who, most of the time, need a little pushing to reach their full potential.

> …ask questions if stuck which no book or teacher could deliver.

… you're saying that LLMs are better than teachers because you can ask LLMs questions and not teachers?! Also, asking questions isn't the only component of learning. A good teacher will know when to not answer a question (or ask one!) and let the student stew and think about it.

I'm not saying AI can help with education. It can—it helps me!—but no hallucinating stochastic machine will have the human insight that a good teacher has. It's not a replacement.


Replies

renewiltordyesterday at 11:41 PM

Well I read ten times as much as you and I think you’re wrong.

show 1 reply