logoalt Hacker News

saberiencetoday at 12:43 PM2 repliesview on HN

One major problem, I don't want a journal with unbreakable encryption where I lose all my data if I ever lose the key.

I already pay for a journaling website where I know I can always recover my journals as long as I have access to my Gmail.

So, while I appreciate this security first mindset, for me it actually becomes less interesting. I want my journal to sync to the cloud, I want to be able to unlock it, I don't want to risk losing years of journals if I forget a single key.


Replies

duskdozertoday at 1:34 PM

>as long as I have access to my Gmail

I think you should be more cautious about relying on the services of a company like Google that can arbitrarily decide to remove your account data or access. Similar, though the person was fortunate enough to regain access: https://hey.paris/posts/appleid/

You can mitigate hardware failure and data loss, especially for a simple key, but you may not be able to prevent Google from deciding your account is gone one day.

holyknighttoday at 1:19 PM

Thanks for the feedback! That point is super valid; that's why I created it with multiple authentication slots in mind (currently, it supports both password and public key authentication) so you can use multiple simultaneously and do not need to rely on one single point of failure.

For example, if you set up a password and a key, you can use your key, and if it gets lost or compromised, you can still log in with the password, remove the old key, and generate a new one.

You can do the same in reverse: just use the password and keep the key in a safe place (like a password manager or a physical USB), and if you lose your password, you can still get access with the key.

Thanks again!