logoalt Hacker News

JKCalhountoday at 3:38 AM3 repliesview on HN

Soul document? More like ego document.

Agents are beginning to look to me like extensions of the operator's ego. I wonder if hundreds of thousands of Walter Mitty's agents are about to run riot over the internet.


Replies

DavidPipertoday at 4:38 AM

I agree with you in concept, but it's still 100% category error to talk like this.

AIs don't have souls. They don't have egos.

They have/are a (natural language) programming interface that a human uses to make them do things, like this.

show 3 replies
koolbatoday at 3:47 AM

> More like ego document.

This metaphor could go so much further. Split it into separate ego, super ego, and id. The id file should be read only.

show 1 reply
ericmcertoday at 6:04 PM

It reminds me of people with big trucks or loud cars. Like "look at what I can do" when someone else engineered, designed and manufactured the entire thing and all they did was step on a pedal.