logoalt Hacker News

pousadalast Friday at 3:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

What does “truly thinking or reasoning” even mean for you?

I don’t think we even have a coherent definition of human intelligence, let alone of non-human ones.


Replies

chpatricklast Friday at 6:44 PM

Everyone knows to really think you need to use your fleshy meat brain, everything else is cheating.

windexh8eryesterday at 2:56 PM

Oh, yes. The trope of "but what does it even mean to think".

If you can't speak, can you think? Yes. Large Language model. Thinking is not predicated on language.

A few good starts for you. Please refute all of these arguments in your spare time to convince me otherwise:

* https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/illusion-of-think... * https://archive.is/FM4y8 * https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/secondary-school-maths-show...

show 1 reply