logoalt Hacker News

hbarkayesterday at 7:47 AM1 replyview on HN

>> Same reason that "Pretend you are an MIT professor" or "You are a leading Python expert" or similar works in prompts.

This pretend-you-are-a-[persona] is cargo cult prompting at this point. The persona framing is just decoration.

A brief purpose statement describing what the skill [skill.md] does is more honest and just as effective.


Replies

rescbryesterday at 2:01 PM

I think it does more harm than good on recent models. The LLM has to override its system prompt to role-play, wasting context and computing cycles instead of working on the task.