logoalt Hacker News

graemepyesterday at 5:44 PM3 repliesview on HN

No. You interpret each document in context and in culture.

For example, you interpret Genesis as a story that makes a point and tell you something - it is like Jesus's parables (no one same says they are literal!). For example, that all human beings are made in the image of God - as we all look different that is clearly not literal. That we are all related and of one ancestry.

On the other hand you interpret the gospels as deliberately written biographies of Jesus. You interpret the epistles as letter written by their author to a particular person or group of people. You interpret the psalms as lyrics.

It is the traditional way of interpreting the Bible and few people had a problem with it until modern times.


Replies

seanw444yesterday at 6:54 PM

I think their point was that Star Wars also has metaphorical lessons to be learned if you're not interpreting it as a literal history lesson.

show 1 reply
9864247888754today at 12:57 AM

What a cheap cop-out to move the goalposts so that only the claims that haven't been disproved yet or are unfalsifiable are meant to be taken literally.

falcor84yesterday at 7:20 PM

> It is the traditional way of interpreting the Bible and few people had a problem with it until modern times.

Sorry to nitpick, but there were quite a lot of "heathens" and "witches" who had faced some problems with the traditional interpretations of the Bible before modern times.