logoalt Hacker News

BrenBarnyesterday at 8:33 PM1 replyview on HN

> I live in an area that has a lot of walkable and bikeable things nearby. There are a lot of people who drive anyway.

The less warm and fuzzy part of this urban-design approach is that it can't just be about making things easier to walk to, it also has to be about making them harder to drive to. For instance, by making parking limited and/or expensive. People tend not to like that idea, although I think there's a good likelihood they'd actually be happy with it if not for the meta-awareness of having "lost" parking.


Replies

Aurornisyesterday at 8:36 PM

People don't like that idea because it's highly exclusionary.

It only sounds good to younger people who don't have any disabilities, kids, grandparents who want to come along, or any number of other valid reasons to walk.

It's also highly indicative of the weather where you're from. Forcing people to bike and walk everywhere sounds a lot better if you're in a moderate climate where bad weather means you need to pack a light jacket and wait for the light rain to stop. Move somewhere with harsh winters and the moralizing about people driving places stops making sense quickly.

show 4 replies