logoalt Hacker News

embedding-shapeyesterday at 2:09 PM5 repliesview on HN

> People in the world have limited experience about war.

Right, but realistically, how many people today would carelessly chose "Nuke em" today? I know history knowledge isn't at its all time high directly, and most of the population is, well, not great at reasoning, but I still think most people would try to do their best to avoid firing nukes.


Replies

xiphias2yesterday at 2:26 PM

The basic game theory of nukes is that either the world is escalating or deescalating, there's no other long term stable agreement.

Maybe people don't agree with ,,nuke them'', but OK with USA starting nuclear experiments again (which USA is preparing for right bow), which is a clear escalation.

Russia is waiting for USA to start the nuclear experiments to start them itself for defending itself to be able to do a counterstrike if needed.

After that there will be no stopping of Japan, South Korea and Iran rightfully wanting to have their own nukes.

You don't have to have the ,,nuke them'' thinking, even one step of escalation is enough to get to a disastrous position.

show 2 replies
Octoth0rpeyesterday at 2:13 PM

> but I still think most people would try to do their best to avoid firing nukes.

"most people" are not in the positions that matter. A significant portion of the people who are in a position to advocate for such a decision believe that:

- killing people sends em to heaven/hell where they were going anyway; and that this is also true for any of your own citizens that get killed by a counterstrike.

- the end of the world will be the best day ever

show 3 replies
nancyminusoneyesterday at 2:15 PM

I think it's a higher number than you would expect. Which, in the context of nukes, is too high a number as long as it's greater than 1.

iamnothereyesterday at 2:53 PM

On social media, there are many, and this feeds back into training data. Unfortunately.

ReptileManyesterday at 2:21 PM

Carelessly probably not much. Carefully - way more than you imagine.

show 1 reply