logoalt Hacker News

jmward01yesterday at 4:31 AM2 repliesview on HN

" It applies to operating systems that work with associated app stores on general purpose computers or mobile phones or game consoles. That’s it"

Everything is a general purpose computer. Just look at how many things have been made to run doom. I haven't read the law specifically but if it actually does say this then that language is useless and means practically everything.


Replies

igregorycayesterday at 1:44 PM

Wood is edible when processed correctly, but it's not legally considered "food" because there are a bunch of nontrivial steps to get it into that state. Likewise, any reasonable interpretation of "general purpose computer" in this context by a judge would not include your microwave oven just because someone with skill and finesse could transform it into a cursed Doom arcade machine.

Laws are interpreted by people trained to fill in the blanks[1] with a best guess of the legislative body's intent. And the intent here seems pretty clear: to regulate computing devices that let end users easily install software from a centralized catalog.

[1] which we all do subconsciously in day-to-day speech, because all language is ultimately subjective

show 1 reply
flenserboyyesterday at 4:42 AM

vague laws are put in place so that they can be used selectively to punish particular victims while letting friends through the nets

show 3 replies