logoalt Hacker News

reliabilityguyyesterday at 2:58 PM5 repliesview on HN

Israel has nuclear weapons. Did it keep them safe?


Replies

alkonautyesterday at 3:29 PM

From invasion or forced regime change? Yes (But I don't think the nukes actually helped in that regard).

show 1 reply
markus_zhangyesterday at 3:02 PM

Pretty safe if you ask me, judging from their…location and historical context.

Manuel_Dyesterday at 3:47 PM

Historically, Israelis have been much safer than most of their neighbors Oct. 7th notwithstanding.

show 1 reply
wat10000yesterday at 5:59 PM

The last time Israel faced an existential threat from its neighbors was 1973. The timeline isn’t entirely clear, but that’s right around the time when they started to have operational nuclear weapons. Many factors contributed to their relative safety since then, but the timing certainly works out for nuclear weapons helping to make that true.

BoredPositronyesterday at 3:34 PM

Well, proximity is a factor...