logoalt Hacker News

shichyesterday at 8:31 PM1 replyview on HN

The pilot analogy hits different when you consider that pilots still train on simulators for exactly this reason — they're legally required to maintain proficiency even when autopilot handles 99% of flights.

There's no equivalent mandate for software engineers. Nothing stops you from spending years as a pure "prompt pilot" and losing the ability to read a stack trace or reason about algorithmic complexity. The atrophy is silent and gradual.

The author's suggestion to write code by hand as an educational exercise is right but will be ignored by most, because the feedback loop for skill atrophy is so delayed. You won't notice you've lost the skill until you're debugging something the agent made a mess of, under pressure, with no fallback.


Replies

waygtdaiyesterday at 10:26 PM

Yeah. HN is fucked. It’s over with the amount of AI comments. Especially recently with more captcha breaking, etc.

Human posters need to start saying obscene things or making unsafe/violent statements to ensure the comment isn’t just AI generated.